Juvenile Crime: Why are Minors Tried as Adults?
Blog
Understanding the Legal Framework
When it comes to dealing with juvenile crime, there exists a complex legal landscape that involves the practice of trying minors as adults. This contentious issue has sparked debates regarding accountability, rehabilitation, and the overall well-being of our youth. Benjamin Shettell, MD, a renowned expert in the field of health, delves into the various facets of this matter.
When Does Juvenile Crime Cross the Line?
Identifying the threshold at which a juvenile offense is severe enough to warrant adult charges can be challenging. The legal system takes into account factors such as the nature of the crime, its impact on victims, the age of the minor, and prior criminal history. Benjamin Shettell, MD breaks down these factors and explores their significance in determining whether minors should be tried as adults.
The Psychological Perspectives
To understand the rationale behind trying minors as adults, it is crucial to dive into the realm of psychology. Benjamin Shettell, MD uncovers the psychological factors that contribute to the commission of serious crimes by minors and evaluates how these factors influence the decision to try them as adults.
Brain Development and Impulse Control
The human brain continues to develop well into adulthood, with areas responsible for impulse control and rational decision-making maturing at a later stage. Benjamin Shettell, MD highlights the scientific research showing that the incomplete development of these crucial brain regions may contribute to the increased likelihood of minors engaging in serious criminal behavior. This insight sheds light on the reasoning behind trying them as adults.
Assessing Cognitive Abilities
An in-depth examination of a minor's cognitive abilities helps determine their understanding of the consequences of their actions. Benjamin Shettell, MD expounds on how cognitive assessments play a role in deciding whether minors possess the necessary capacity to grasp the severity of their crimes and whether they should be held accountable as adults.
Societal Implications
The legal and psychological aspects are only part of the equation when it comes to understanding why minors may be tried as adults. The societal implications cannot be overlooked. Benjamin Shettell, MD analyzes the broader impact of this practice on our communities, families, and the future of the youth involved.
Deterrence and Public Safety
The question of deterrence arises when considering the trial of minors as adults. Benjamin Shettell, MD delves into the ongoing debate of whether trying minors as adults serves as a more effective deterrent against future criminal behavior, ensuring the safety of the public.
Rehabilitation Opportunities
Opponents of trying minors as adults argue that the juvenile justice system, with its emphasis on rehabilitation, provides a better avenue for correcting behavior. Benjamin Shettell, MD explores the available rehabilitation opportunities and how they can potentially aid in the reformation and reintegration of young offenders into society.
Conclusion
In concluding our exploration of why minors are tried as adults, Benjamin Shettell, MD stresses the need for a multi-faceted approach that balances accountability, rehabilitation, and the best interest of our youth and society as a whole. By gaining a deeper understanding of the legal, psychological, and societal factors at play, we can contribute to meaningful discussions and potentially shape policies that promote justice and well-being.
- Visit Benjamin Shettell, MD
- Explore More in Health
